Current understanding of how climate change affects seabirds varies between regions and species in the North-East Atlantic

Shags and Guillemots, Mike Toms / BTO

Author(s): Johnston, D.T., Humphreys, E.M., Davies, J.G., Evans, T., Howells, R.J. & Pearce-Higgins, J.W.

Published: January 2025  

Journal: Marine Ecology Progress Series Volume: 755

Digital Identifier No. (DOI): 10.3354/meps14785

View journal article

BTO-led research identifies key gaps in our knowledge and understanding of how climate change is affecting seabirds.

Seabirds are particularly vulnerable to the effects of climate change, with previous research by BTO projecting significant declines over the coming decades. Seabird populations respond to climate change through changes
in abundance, breeding productivity, survival rates, and phenology. However, while the impacts of climate change on certain species and regions are well-studied, the majority of species and sites remain understudied. This may may limit our understanding of the mechanisms linking climate change to seabird population change, which is vital for identifying which species are at particular risk and formulating conservation responses.

In this paper, the authors reviewed the scientific literature from 1970 to 2022 for the 25 seabird species that breed in the UK and the Republic of Ireland. The search was focused on the North-East Atlantic region. The findings revealed significant gaps, in that only six seabird species have been the focus of more than 10 applicable studies, and a mere three (Kittiwake, Guillemot and Shag) have been the subject of more than 20 applicable studies. Furthermore, the majority of studies were conducted in the North Sea (particularly on the Isle of May), which may not be representative of oceanic conditions or those of other regional seas.

Of the drivers of population change, breeding productivity was the most monitored demographic rate across seabird species. This focus may lead to important mechanisms that affect other demographic rates, such as survival, being overlooked, compounding any biases in understanding introduced by the focus on particular species and locations.

Nevertheless, the literature does consistently highlight the importance of both climate impacts cascading through the food chain and severe storm events affecting seabirds, causing starvation and wrecks. In response, conservation action should prioritise the sustainable management of fish stocks near breeding colonies, and coastal management to protect vulnerable colonies from storm events.

Abstract

Climate change is regarded as a major threat to seabird populations globally. While the impacts on certain species are well-studied, the majority remain understudied, which may limit our understanding of the key mechanisms linking climate change to population dynamics. This information is important to identify vulnerable species and inform potential conservation responses. To address this gap, we reviewed literature on the impacts of climate change on the demography of 25 seabird species breeding in the UK and Republic of Ireland from relevant studies conducted within the wider North-East Atlantic. We found regional and species-specific variations in research effort, with the North Sea being the most studied area. The most frequently studied species were common guillemot Uria aalge (n = 35), black-legged kittiwake Rissa tridactyla (n = 29), and European shag Gulosus aristotelis (n = 25). Breeding productivity and population abundance were the primary demographic parameters investigated. The North Atlantic Oscillation and sea surface temperature were commonly used to describe climate influences, often linked to bottom-up mechanisms affecting demography through changes in prey availability. Breeding productivity was the most monitored demographic rate across species; this may lead to important mechanisms affecting other demographic rates, such as survival, being overlooked. Regional and species-specific disparities in research could bias the identification of key mechanisms. Despite these uncertainties, current literature highlights the importance of climate impacts through the food chain and severe storm events affecting seabirds. In response, climate change adaptation should prioritise management of fish stocks near breeding colonies and coastal management to protect vulnerable colonies from storm events.

Notes

This paper is an output from the Marine Protected Areas Management and Monitoring (MarPAMM) project. This project has been supported by the EU’s INTERREG VA Programme, managed by the Special EU Programmes Body (SEUPB).
Staff Author(s)


Related content